Share

POLITICS

Morning Examiner: Napolitano exposes fraud at core of immigration reform

|
Politics,Beltway Confidential,Conn Carroll

When Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., made the rounds on conservative talk radio pitching his immigration reform plan to the base of the Republican Party, he made heightened border security the centerpiece of his pitch. “If, in fact, this bill does not have real triggers in there,” Rubio told Rush Limbaugh in January, “if there is not language in this bill that guarantees that nothing else will happen unless these enforcement mechanisms are in place, I won’t support it.”

But just two weeks later, it became abundantly clear that one party already thought the borders were perfectly secure. Department of Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano told Congress in mid-February that, “Our borders have, in fact, never been stronger.”

And then yesterday, at a Christian Science Monitor breakfast she went a step further. “We’re confident that the border is as secure as it’s ever been,” Napolitano said, echoing her previous congressional testimony. But she also added, “Once people really look at the whole system and how it works, relying on one thing as a so-called trigger is not the way to go.”

Asked to clarify Napolitano’s statement during the White House press briefing, President Obama’s Press Secretary Jay Carney said, “Certainly the facts are there when it comes to the resources that have been applied to border security — the doubling of border security agents, as well as the other metrics that you will often hear Secretary Napolitano or others discuss. … And I would note … the progress that has been made on this very important issue, border security… many of the metrics that were put forward then have been met — the goals and the targets that were said to have to be achieved before we could move forward have been met.”

This puts Rubio and the rest of the Republicans in the Gang of Ocho in a tough spot. Either they agree with Napolitano and the White House that the borders are already secure and no new “triggers” need to be met, or they agree with Limbaugh and the conservative base that our borders are not secure and more needs to be done. It is a simple factual dispute. They cannot have it both ways.

Back in January, Rubio promised Limbaugh, “To the point of them not wanting to do the security, look, all I can tell you is that that’s a big issue for me and that’s why I’m involved in this process. I have no reason to believe it won’t happen, but if it doesn’t, then I’ll come back to you and say, ‘Look, it didn’t. We tried. They put that in the principles, but then they drafted a bill that didn’t do it, and I couldn’t support it.’”

We still have not seen any legislation from the Gang of Ocho. But when we do, it better have real border security triggers that have not already been met. Otherwise, Rubio must follow through on his promise and walk away.

From The Washington Examiner
Examiner Editorial: The culture war is all Obama has left
Michael Barone: Republicans grow less hawkish in wake of Iraq War
Conn Carroll: Xbox habit earns immigrant legal status

In Other News
The Associated Press, Health overhaul to raise claims cost 32 pct: Insurance companies will have to pay out an average of 32 percent more for medical claims on individual health policies under President Obama’s overhaul, the nation’s leading group of financial risk analysts has estimated. That’s likely to increase premiums for Americans buying individual plans.
The Wall Street Journal, College Grads May Be Stuck in Low-Skill Jobs: The recession left millions of college-educated Americans working in coffee shops and retail stores. Now, new research suggests their job prospects may not improve much when the economy rebounds.
The New York Times, First Woman Is Chosen to Lead Secret Service: President Obama on Tuesday appointed Julia A. Pierson, a longtime Secret Service agent, as the first woman to head the agency best known for protecting the president, vice president and their families.
The Washington Post, Dow 30 firms shows declining tax burden: Most of the 30 companies listed on the country’s most famous stock index, the Dow Jones industrial average, have seen a dramatically smaller percentage of their profits go to U.S. coffers over time, even as their share prices have driven the Dow to an all-time high.
The Los Angeles Times, Court seems willing to let gays marry in California: The sharply divided justices also appear uncomfortable with legalizing same-sex marriage nationwide.

Lefty Playbook
Adam Serwer lists the 7 worst things Antonin Scalia has said or written about homosexuality.
Talking Points Memo attacks Republicans for complaining about sequester cuts in their district.
Suzy Khimm explains why the AFL-CIO wants foreign workers paid more than native-born ones.

Righty Playbook
Ed Morrissey says government should get out of the marriage business.
Avik Roy explains Why conservatives will win the health-care debates of the future.
Ilya Shapiro predicts the Supreme Court will weasel its way out of yesterday’s gay marriage case.

View article comments Leave a comment