June 20, 2013

Analysis

Examiner Local Editorial: Red Line Crash still haunts Metro

BY: Examiner Editorial DECEMBER 22, 2012 | 8:00 PM
Leave a comment

Financial settlements with the victims of Metro's June 22, 2009, Red Line crash that killed nine people and injured more than 80 have already reached tens of millions of dollars -- and the final reckoning is far from over.

As The Washington Examiner's Kytja Weir reported last Tuesday, the $48.5 million paid out in the last fiscal year alone amounted to 3 percent of the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority's entire operating budget. That's enough to purchase 24 new rail cars or 80 hybrid buses -- and it wasn't covered by insurance.

In the past five years, Metro has paid out $173 million in legal claims, including an undisclosed amount for a Metrobus crash in 2008 that killed a California man and injured his wife and two children. But the claims escalated following the Fort Totten accident, the worst in Metro's history.

In February, Weir reported that Metro and its three track equipment manufacturers -- Alstom Signaling, Ansaldo STS USA and ARINC -- filed court documents announcing they would "stipulate to liability" in four remaining cases in order to avoid "significant risks and costs" associated with litigation. This first public admission of guilt, more than two years after the crash, no doubt saved the transit agency millions of additional dollars, but it also confirmed the National Transportation Safety Board's findings that the tragic accident could have been prevented had Metro not ignored the many warning signs and kept its equipment in good repair.

That was cold comfort to the families of Ana Fernandez and LaVonda King, who between them left eight young children motherless.

Metro riders and local taxpayers will be paying for this catastrophe for some time to come. Because victims had until June 22 of this year to file claims, and some settlements made last year were not finalized by the end of the fiscal year, the financial fallout is still not over.

As a result of the Red Line accident, Metrorail trains are still manually operated because the transit agency still cannot guarantee that the computerized signaling system that failed in 2009 won't fail again. Metro's annual liability insurance premiums have nearly doubled. These costs are passed on to passengers and local jurisdictions that fund Metro.

Because the settlements are confidential, the final cost of the Red Line crash will never be fully known, although it will surely top $100 million. And that's in addition to the incalculable pain and suffering caused by Metro's negligence.

View article comments Leave a comment

More from washingtonexaminer.com

From the Weekly Standard

  • June 17, 1953

    Today, speaking at the Brandenburg Gate, President Obama paid appropriate tribute to the brave East Germans who rebelled 60 years ago against Communist dictatorship:

    Read More...
  • Problems of the Second Generation

    The Boston Marathon bombings highlighted, once again, the challenges of assimilating Muslim youth. And while the onus of accountability ought not rest exclusively on Muslim Americans, it...

    Read More...
  • Release Osama Bin Laden’s Files on Taliban

    The Obama administration announced on Tuesday that it was moving forward with its attempt to negotiate with the Taliban, which has opened a long-awaited political office in Doha, Qatar. The...

    Read More...