Policy: Law

MORNING EXAMINER: Supreme Court will decide if Obamacare can ignore First Amendment

By |
Beltway Confidential,Mark Tapscott,Morning Examiner,Obamacare,Supreme Court,Health Care,Abortion,First Amendment,Law

Those nine black-robed justices on the U.S. Supreme Court have agreed to decide two of the most important cases in the panel's history.

The cases are Sebelius v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. and Conestoga Wood Specialties Corp. v. Sebelius. Both are centered on the question of whether the federal government can mandate a business to provide a service that conflicts with the owners' religious beliefs.

Both cases arose from Obamacare's birth control mandate, which attorneys for each of the plaintiffs argue violates the First Amendment's bar on Congress making any law respecting religious freedom.

A fundamental issue

The issue here is fundamental: Does any individual have to check his or her religious faith, or lack thereof, at the door when entering the public square, including in the place where he or she earns a living?

Hobby Lobby is being represented by the Beckett Fund, while Conestoga Wood is being represented by the Alliance Defending Freedom.

Hobby Lobby is an Oklahoma City-based retail chain owned by founder David Green and his family, who are Baptists. Conestoga Wood in Lancaster County, PA., is owned by David Hahn and his family, who are Mennonite Christians.

What's at stake?

There are four major concerns involved in these two cases, according to ADF:

* "The freedom to live according to our faith and to honor God in our work.

* "Freedom from the threat of crippling fines for resisting illegal government mandates.

* "Freedom from government intrusion on a family business' private moral decisions.

* "The free and full participation of people of faith in all areas of public life, including the marketplace."

Supreme Court cases don't often get more fundamental than that. The High Court will combine the two cases in one decision that will be announced sometime in 2014.

On today's washingtonexaminer.com

Editorial: Wasteful agency's director resigns following Washington Examiner Watchdog investigative series.

EXography: Survey finds doctors rebelling against Obamacare, famous hospitals declining to participate.

Joseph Lawler: Obama moves to limit political expression of non-profits.

Sean Higgins: It's official, Obamacare tax change will help union plans.

Philip Klein: Obama's tortured history with Iran sanctions.

Noemie Emery: Obama is no longer invincible.

In other news

The New York Times: Obama White House urges caution on Obamacare website.

Time Magazine: China says it let U.S. fly B-52s across dispute air defense zone.

ABC News: CBS asks Lara Logan to take leave after flawed Benghazi report.

The Washington Post: Microsoft to bolster security against NSA.

New York Post: Obama tells pen pal Obamacare "not the political thing to do."

The Wall Street Journal: Surging Nasdaq reflects economic shifts.

Chicago Tribune: Mayor moves to limit medical marijuana.

Lefty Playbook

Talking Points Memo: The birth of Obamacare McCarthyism.

Mother Jones: The government's secret plan to kill the Internet explained.

Washington Monthly: Time for a Plan C.

Bonus must-read!

Harper's: Can Amazon change its predatory ways?

Righty Playbook

American Spectator: Why America can't keep its own secrets.

American Thinker: America as protector of Putin, Assad, and Khamenei

Washington Free Beacon: Iran, North Korea missile cooperation undermines Geneva deal.

Bonus must-read

Weekly Standard: The "other" Kennedy assassination.

View article comments Leave a comment