Comments on:

Movie review: 'Oblivion' thoughtful, but with plenty of action

Back to the article » |
What's the difference between a derivative knock-off and a clever or loving homage? Like beauty, it seems to be found in the eye of the beholder. Critics loved 2011's "Super 8," J.J. Abrams' rough tribute to Steven Spielberg that felt exactly like a Steven Spielberg film. But so far, they're rather less enamored of "Oblivion," Joseph Kosinski's tribute to 1970s and '80s science-fiction films....

To learn more about commenting on and our community guidelines, please see our comments FAQ.