Return to Washington Examiner Homepage
May 21, 2013 | 07:55 PM
politics
Washington D.C. weather
Politics

Obama thinks John Roberts made a political decision in Obamacare case

October 25, 2012 | 4:25 pm | Modified: October 25, 2012 at 4:35 pm
Leave a comment

President Obama suggested that Chief Justice John Roberts upheld Obamacare under the taxing power because he wanted to “preserve the law” while leaving the door open to weakening Commerce Clause precedents.

“It was interesting to see them, or Justice Roberts in particular, take the approach that this was constitutional under the taxing power,” Obama told Rolling Stone in an interview published today. “The truth is that if you look at the precedents dating back to the 1930s, this was clearly constitutional under the Commerce Clause. I think Justice Roberts made a decision that allowed him to preserve the law but allowed him to keep in reserve the desire, maybe, to scale back Congress’ power under the Commerce Clause in future cases.”

That’s not far from Charles Krauthammer’s take on the decision. “The law stands, thus obviating any charge that a partisan Court overturned duly passed legislation,” he wrote for National Review. “And yet at the same time the Commerce Clause is reined in. By denying that it could justify the imposition of an individual mandate, Roberts draws the line against the inexorable decades-old expansion of congressional power under the Commerce Clause fig leaf. The law stands, thus obviating any charge that a partisan Court overturned duly passed legislation. Law upheld, Supreme Court’s reputation for neutrality maintained. Commerce Clause contained, constitutional principle of enumerated powers reaffirmed.” Obama predicted that future generations will view Obamacare as “the last piece to our basic social compact.” He also approved of “Fair Shake” as a two-word distillation of his domestic agenda, a la FDR’s New Deal. “I’d be comfortable with that, and hearing it from a historian, it sounds pretty good to me,” Obama said of “Fair Shake.”

 

From WeeklyStandard.com

  • He’s No Nixon

    The thoughtful Carl Cannon has written a piece, " Richard Milhous Obama ," concluding that our current president has more in common with our 37th than President Obama's partisans would like to...

    Read More...

  • IRS's Lerner Had History of Harassment, Inappropriate Religious Inquiries at FEC

    Perhaps no other IRS official is more intimately associated with the tax agency's growing scandal than Lois Lerner, director of the IRS’s Exempt Organizations Division. Since admitting the IRS...

    Read More...

  • Yet Another Obamacare Design Flaw

    The more the evidence emerges, the more one has to wonder: Could Obamacare have been designed any more poorly? Even those who don’t mind Obamacare’s striking consolidation of power and money...

    Read More...