June 19, 2013

Putting out a 'Fire' with deadly gasoline

BY: KELLY JANE TORRANCE OCTOBER 4, 2012 | 8:00 PM
Leave a comment

You know those episodes of "House" in which Hugh Laurie, or one of the members of his team, hits upon the right diagnosis for the wrong reasons? He might guess correctly that a patient has a blood infection, but in getting the cause of that infection wrong, doesn't treat the source. Sometimes he even makes the problem worse.

That's what "Escape Fire: The Fight to Rescue American Healthcare" is like. Except it doesn't offer the solace of Laurie's piercing blue eyes in exchange for its tendentious diagnosis.

What's really frightening about "Escape Fire" isn't the picture of a costly and ineffective system it presents. It's that this documentary is being released just over a month before the presidential election, with a clear eye to influencing the results.

On screen
'Escape Fire: The Fight to Rescue American Healthcare'
Zero stars
Stars: Don Berwick, Shannon Brownlee, Steve Burd
Director: Susan Froemke, Matthew Heineman
Rated: PG-13 for some thematic material
Running time: 99 minutes

There's no question the American health care system is broken. But it's not for the reasons directors Susan Froemke and Matthew Heineman posit. They lay a great deal of blame on the pharmaceutical industry, arguing that Americans are overprescribed because of the money-hungry industry.

In fact, new drugs have brought costs down. It's a lot less expensive to treat a patient with heart disease with a handful of pills than to require him to undergo open heart surgery down the line. Froemke and Heineman spend a lot of time on the rising rates of diabetes. But it's a perfect example of how a drug discovery has helped saved lives and money.

Of course, now that people are living longer thanks to these new advances, there's a greater burden on the health care system. It's a rather simple cause and effect, but none of the "experts" in this doc have figured it out.

The kind of advice offered here, instead, ranges from the obvious to the dangerous. In the former category is the idea that we should eat better -- more whole foods, less junk food. McDonald's isn't trying to kill its customers by pricing salads more than hamburgers, though. Supply and demand is another basis lesson these filmmakers never learned.

By promoting the work of Dean Ornish and Andrew Weil, "Escape Fire" could do more real damage than a thousand Big Macs. Ornish might promote the benefits of yoga in bringing down stress, and hence helping heart disease. But nobody should ignore their doctor's prescriptions in favor of lying on a yoga mat or undergoing acupuncture -- another "alternative" therapy trumpeted in this film.

View article comments Leave a comment
Author:

Kelly Jane Torrance

Washington Examiner Movie Critic
The Washington Examiner

More from washingtonexaminer.com

From the Weekly Standard

  • June 17, 1953

    Today, speaking at the Brandenburg Gate, President Obama paid appropriate tribute to the brave East Germans who rebelled 60 years ago against Communist dictatorship:

    Read More...
  • Problems of the Second Generation

    The Boston Marathon bombings highlighted, once again, the challenges of assimilating Muslim youth. And while the onus of accountability ought not rest exclusively on Muslim Americans, it...

    Read More...
  • Release Osama Bin Laden’s Files on Taliban

    The Obama administration announced on Tuesday that it was moving forward with its attempt to negotiate with the Taliban, which has opened a long-awaited political office in Doha, Qatar. The...

    Read More...