Return to Washington Examiner Homepage
May 18, 2013 | 07:08 PM
politics
Washington D.C. weather
Politics

The ‘redefine rape’ lie

September 5, 2012 | 11:22 pm | Modified: September 5, 2012 at 11:40 pm
Leave a comment

Many Democratic speakers, including Sandra Fluke, charged this week that Paul Ryan tried to “redefine rape.” This line of attack stems from Republican legislation that included the term “forcible rape.” As an example of the liberal critique of this legislation, here’s Nick Baumann at Mother Jones: “Rape is only really rape if it involves force. So says the new House Republican majority as it now moves to change abortion law.”

But here’s a serious problem with this line of attack: the term “forcible rape” wasn’t invented by Republican pro-lifers.

For instance, the Democratic House and Democratic Senate in 1994 passed, and Democratic President Bill Clinton signed a crime bill that included a line “The term ‘part 1 violent crimes’ means murder and non-negligent manslaughter, forcible rape…

Also, in 1990, the Democratic Congress passed the “Hate Crimes Statistics Act” — with Ted Kennedy and Barbara Mikulski among the 60 co-sponsors — which required statistics be kept on bias-motivated “crimes of murder, non-negligent manslaughter; forcible rape…”

Was Barbara Mikulski redefining rape? Did Bill Clinton “redefine rape.”

The word shows up in many parts of criminal codes in the U.S. When the District of Columbia passed a hate-crimes law, it distinguished “forcible rape” from other rapes.

Look at California’s official crime statistics — they have a category for forcible rape.

You may think distinctions between “forcible rape” and statutory rape are bad policy, but you can’t claim that Paul Ryan, Todd Akin, or any other current Republican lawmaker invented the term in an effort to “redefine rape.” “Forcible Rape” is already part of our federal criminal code, for better or worse.

Democrats make that charge from the podium, but politicians say a lot of things.

From WeeklyStandard.com

  • Ideological Revenue Service

    With three different scandals threatening to consume the White House last week—the Benghazi cover-up, the Justice Department’s seizure of the phone records of dozens of Associated Press...

    Read More...

  • The Real Scandal

    Everyone in Washington, except those in the crosshairs, likes a good scandal, and THE WEEKLY STANDARD is no exception. What’s more, in the case of the Obama administration, comeuppance is well...

    Read More...

  • When It Rains, It Pours

    There is no curse on the second term of presidents. When presidents lose credibility, when trust vanishes and their word is no longer accepted, they have only themselves to blame. That was true...

    Read More...